The status of the Romanian literary avant-garde after 2000: from marginalization to recovery
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35824/sjrs.v7i1.25859Keywords:
Romanian avant-garde literature, marginal(ized) avant-garde, literary studies, literary canon, literary influencesAbstract
The present paper proposes a theoretical approach related to the critical reception of the Romanian literary avant-garde after 2000, a literary phenomenon in‑between marginalization and recovery tendencies. Starting from interwar critical studies from Romania (E. Lovinescu, G. Călinescu, etc.), with predominantly negative perspectives regarding the critical reception of the avant-garde, we will observe how certain clichés of the reception of the phenomenon, seen as “extremist”, as marginal, were perpetuated, with the “barrier” of the apparently impossible literary canonization. After 2000, however, literary studies discuss the historicization of the avant-garde phenomenon, which therefore became canonical in Romanian literary history. However, several elements of the “niche” avant-garde remained in the subsidiary, in the “shadow”. This is what we call the marginal(ized), the secondary avant-garde, which includes a series of less known and researched avant-garde writers, but who contributed to the complex shaping of the avant-garde imaginary.
We will analyse several types of works published after 2000, in order to highlight the complexity of the avant-garde, under constant recovery: literary anthologies (Ion Pop, Nicolae Bârna), avant-garde dictionaries (Lucian Pricop, Dan Grigorescu), several critical studies after 2000 (Ion Bogdan Lefter, Ovidiu Morar, Emilia Drogoreanu, Paul Cernat, Dan Gulea, Emanuel Modoc, Delia Ungureanu, Daniel Clinci, Petre Răileanu, Gabriela Glăvan, Ion Pop, etc.). Many of them focus on the recovery trends of some forgotten writers, with the possibility of their inclusion in the central, canonical avant-garde, while other studies pursue new research methodologies, such as the avant-garde seen in a transnational context, in world literature context, etc.
An issue that we develop in the context of this extended future research, which is also highlighted upon in the present work, is that of post-Urmuz epigonism within Romanian literary avant-garde, a fact that explains the placement of many writers in the sphere of critical marginalization. Thus, many texts by less researched writers are forgotten, being always associated with the central avant-garde models, especially Urmuz, but also Tristan Tzara or other influential writers within the central avant‑garde groups. It is precisely this problem that made us analyse the way in which the writers who are part of the marginal dimension of the avant-garde are recovered through contemporary literary studies from Romania.
References
Balázs, I. J. (2009). Avangarda în literatura maghiară din România [Avant-Garde in Hungarian literature from Romania]. Timișoara: Bastion.
Bârna, N. (2017). Avangarda literară românească [Romanian literary avant-garde]. Chișinău: Știința.
Buciu, M. V. (2006). Avangarda și neoavangarda în literatura română [Avant-Garde and neo-avant-garde in Romanian literature]. Craiova: Tipografia Universității din Craiova.
Bürger, P. (2010). Avant-garde and neo-avant-garde: An attempt to answer certain critics of “Theory of the Avant-Garde”. New Literary History, 41(4), 695 715. Retrieved 31 October, 2023, from https://www.jstor.org/stable/23012702.
Călinescu, G. (1968). Principii de estetică [Principles of aesthetics]. București: Minerva. [with various editions: 1939, 1974, 1979, 1998, 2003].
Călinescu, G. (1982). Istoria literaturii române de la origini până în prezent [The history of Romanian literature from its origins to the present]. București: Minerva. (1st edition in 1941).
Călinescu, M. (1970). Eseuri despre literatura modernă [Essays on modern literature]. București: Eminescu.
Călinescu, M. (1972). Conceptul modern de poezie: De la romantism la avangardă [The modern concept of poetry. From romanticism to the avant-garde]. București: Eminescu. (2nd and 3rd editions in 2002 and 2017).
Călinescu, M. (2005). Cinci fețe ale modernității: modernism, avangardă, decadență, kitsch, postmodernism [Five faces of modernity: Modernism, avant-garde, decadence, kitsch, postmodernism]. Iași: Polirom. (1st edition in 1996).
Cernat, P. (2007). Avangarda românească și complexul periferiei: primul val [The Romanian avant-garde and the periphery complex: The first wave]. București: Cartea Românească.
Cernat, P. (2018). Vase comunicante: (Inter)fețe ale avangardei românești interbelice [Communicating vessels: (Inter)faces of the Romanian interwar avant garde]. București: Polirom.
Cioculescu, Ș. (1972). Aspecte lirice contemporane [Contemporary lyrical aspects]. București: Minerva. (1st edition in 1942).
Clinci, D. (2014). Avangardă și experiment: De la estetica negativă la cultura postmodernă [Avant-garde and experiment: From negative aesthetics to postmodern culture]. București: Tracus Arte.
Codrescu, A. (2009). The posthuman Dada guide: Tzara & Lenin play chess. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Constantinescu, P. (1971). Scrieri [Writings], vol. V. București: Minerva.
Constantinescu, P. (1972). Scrieri [Writings], vol. VI. București: Minerva.
Cornis-Pope, M. (1996). The unfinished battles: Romanian postmodernism before and after 1989. Iași: Polirom.
Crohmălniceanu, O. S. (1972). Literatura română între cele două războaie mondiale [Romanian literature between the two world wars], vol. I. București: Minerva.
Crohmălniceanu, O. S. (2001). Evreii în mișcarea de avangardă românească [Jews in the Romanian avant-garde movement]. București: Hasefer.
Drăgănescu, M. (1909). Scumpe confrate [Dear brother]. Democrația, I(19), p. 6.
Drogoreanu, E. (2004). Influențe ale futurismului italian asupra avangardei românești: Sincronie și specificitate [Influences of Italian futurism on the Romanian avant-Garde: Synchronicity and Specificity]. Pitești: Paralela 45.
Duda, G. (1997). Literatura românească de avangardă [Romanian avant-garde literature]. București: Humanitas.
Emilian, C. I. (1932). Anarhismul poetic: Studiu critic [Poetic anarchism: Critical study]. București: Tipografia „Bucovina”.
Finkenthal, M. (2013). D. Trost. Între realitatea visului și visul ca realitate [ D. Trost. between the reality of the dream and the dream as reality]. București: Tracus Arte.
Glăvan, G. (2014). Viraj în ireal: Modernități particulare în literatura română interbelică [Turn into the unreal: Particular modernities in interwar Romanian literature]. Timișoara: Editura Universității de Vest.
Grigorescu, D. (2005). Dicționarul avangardelor [The Dictionary of the avant-gardes]. București: Editura Enciclopedică.
Gulea, D. (2007). Domni, tovarăși, camarazi. O evoluție a avangardei române [Gentlemen, partners, and comrades: An evolution of the Romanian avant garde]. Pitești: Paralela 45.
Gulea, D. (2016). Marginaliile avangardelor [The avant-gardes marginalia]. București: Tracus Arte.
Gyr, R. (1937). Scurt bilanț al unei anarhii de import [Brief account of an import anarchy]. Porunca vremii [The command of time], VI(716), p. 2.
Hentea, M. (2014). TaTa DADA. The real life and celestial adventures of Tristan Tzara. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Lăcătuș, A. (2002). Urmuz: Monografie, antologie comentată, receptare critică [Urmuz: Monography, commented anthology, critical reception]. Brașov: Aula.
Lefter, I. B. (2000). Recapitularea modernității: Pentru o nouă istorie a literaturii române [Modernity revised: To a new history of Romanian literature]. Pitești: Paralela 45.
Lovinescu, E. (1981). Istoria literaturii române contemporane (II) [History of Contemporary Romanian Literature (II)]. București: Minerva.
Marino, A. (1973). Dicționar de idei literare [Dictionary of literary ideas], vol. I A G. București: Eminescu.
Mincu, M. (1983). Avangarda literară românească [Romanian literary avant garde]. București: Minerva. [2nd and 3rd editions in 1999 and 2006].
Modoc, E. (2020). Internaționala periferiilor: Rețeaua avangardelor din Europa Centrală și de Est [The international of peripheries: Avant-garde networks of East Central Europe]. București: Muzeul Literaturii Române.
Morar, O. (2003). Avatarurile suprarealismului românesc [The avatars of Romanian surrealism]. București: Univers.
Morar, O. (2005). Avangardismul românesc [Romanian avant-garde]. București: Ideea Europeană.
Morar, O. (2014). Scriitori evrei din România [Jewish writers from Romania]. București: Hasefer.
Pană, S. (1969). Antologia literaturii române de avangardă și câteva desene din epocă [Anthology of Romanian avant-garde literature and some drawings from the era]. București: Editura pentru Literatură.
Petrescu, C. (1925). Manifeste: suprarealism, dada [Manifestoes: Surrealism, dada]. Cuvântul Literar și Artistic [The literary and artistic word], II(22), p. 4.
Petrescu, R. I. (2003). Privirea Medusei: Poezia lui B. Fundoianu/Benjamin Fondane [The gaze of Medusa: The poetry of B. Fundoianu/Benjamin Fondane]. Iași: Editura Universității „Alexandru Ioan Cuza”.
Pricop, L. (2003). Dicționar de avangardă literară românească: Scriitori, reviste, curente [Dictionary of the Romanian literary avant-garde: Writers, magazines, movements]. București: Tritonic.
Pop, I. (1969). Avangardismul poetic românesc: Eseuri [Romanian poetic avant-garde: Essays]. București: Editura pentru literatură.
Pop, I. (2016). Avangarda românească [Romanian avant-garde]. București: Editura Academiei Române.
Pop, I. (2017). Avangarda în literatura română [Avant-Garde in Romanian literature]. Chișinău: Cartier.
Popescu, S. (2000). Salvarea speciei. Despre suprarealism și Gellu Naum / Saving the species. On surrealism and Gellu Naum. București: Editura Fundației Culturale Române.
Răileanu, P. (2016). DADA în direct, urmat de Tristan Tzara, schiță de portret [DADA live, followed by Tristan Tzara, portrait sketch]. București: Tracus Arte.
Sandqvist, T. (2006). Dada East: The Romanians of abaret Voltaire. Cambridge: MIT Press. [2nd edition in 2010].
Scarlat, M. (1986). Istoria poeziei românești [History of Romanian poetry], vol. III. București: Minerva.
Sebastian, M. (1994). Opere [Works], vol. I. București: Minerva.
Simion, E. (1984). Scriitori români de azi [Romanian writers of today], vol. III. București: Cartea Românească.
Spiridon, M., Gutthy, A., Jerzak, K. (2006). Paris as a Constitutive East-Central European Topos: The Case of Polish and Romanian Literatures. In Marcel Cornis-Pope, John Neubauer (Ed.), History of the Literary Cultures of East Central Europe. Junctures and Disjunctures In the 19th and 20th Centuries (pp. 428-440). Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins Publishing Company.
Streinu, V. (1977). Pagini de critică literară. [Pages of literary criticism], vol. V. București: Minerva.
Terian, A. (2013). Critica de export: teorii, contexte, ideologii [Export criticism: Theories, contexts, ideologies]. București: Muzeul Literaturii Române.
Velescu, C. R. (2007). Victor Brauner d’après Duchamp, sau, Drumul pictorului către un suprarealism “bine temperat” [Victor Brauner after Duchamp, or the Painter’s path towards a “well-tempered” surrealism]. București: Institutul Cultural Român.
Velescu, C. R. (2013). Avant-gardes et modernités: Brâncuși, Duchamp, Brauner, Voronca, Tzara & comp [Avant-Gardes and modernities: Brâncuși, Duchamp, Brauner, Voronca, Tzara & comp]. București: Institutul Cultural Român.
Yaari, M. (2014). ‟Infra-Noir”, un et multiple: Un groupe surréaliste entre Bucarest et Paris, 1945-1947 [“Infra-Noir”, one and multiple: A surrealist group between Bucharest and Paris, 1945-1947]. Berna: Peter Lang.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Alexandru Foitoș
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
a. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
b. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
c. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).