Skip to main content Skip to main navigation menu Skip to site footer
Research Articles
Submitted: 2019-05-27
Published: 2020-07-16

Cetacean Property: A Hegelish Account of Nonhuman Property

Georgia State University
Hegel dolphins property identity agency habitat Locke

Abstract

First, I spell out the details of a Hegelish conception of property. To clarify what makes this account unique, I compare it to a labor-mixing conception of property that finds its origins in Locke. In doing so, I highlight strengths of a Hegelish account of property over its Lockean alternative. Then, I show how dolphins, consistent with a Hegelish account of property, are property owners of their oceanic habitats. Finally, I outline the strengths of a Hegelish account of property as it would apply to dolphins and perhaps other nonhuman animals in protecting them. It is not my aim to argue that a Hegelish account of nonhuman property is the only viable path toward recognizing nonhuman property. Rather, I hope to show that such an account holds promise as a tool in the conceptual toolbox handled by theorists of the political turn in animal ethics.

References

  1. Andrews, K. et al. (2017). Chimpanzee Rights: The Philosophers’ Brief. Philadelphia, PA: Routledge.
  2. Benjamin, A. (2007). What if the Other were an Animal? Hegel on Jews, Animals and Disease. Critical Horizons 8(1), 61–77.
  3. Blattner, C.B. et al. (2020). Animal Agency in Community: A Political Multispecies Ethnography of VINE Sanctuary. Politics and Animals 6(1), 1–22.
  4. Bruck, J. (2013). Decades-long social memory in bottlenose dolphins. Proceedings: Biological Sciences, 280(1768), 1–6.
  5. Caldwell, M., & Caldwell, D. (1965). Individualized Whistle Contours in Bottle-nosed Dolphins. Nature, 207, 434–5.
  6. Carlucci, R. et al. (2018). Site fidelity, residency and habitat use of the Risso’s dolphin Grampus griseus in the Gulf of Taranto (Northern Ionian Sea, Central-eastern Mediterranean Sea) by photo-identification. IEEE International Workshop on Metrology for the Sea; Learning to Measure Sea Health Parameters (MetroSea), 173-177.
  7. Chan, S., & Harris, J. (2011). Human Animals and Nonhuman Persons. The Oxford Handbook of Animal Ethics. T.L. Beauchamp and R.G. Frey (eds.). New York: Oxford University Press, 304–31.
  8. Cochrane, A. (2009). Do Animals Have an Interest in Liberty? Political Studies 57(1), 660–679.
  9. Cochrane, A. (2012). Animal Rights Without Liberation: Applied Ethics and Human Obligations. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
  10. Cochrane, A. (2018). Sentientist Politics: A Theory of Global Inter-Species Justice. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
  11. Cooke, S. (2017). Animal Kingdoms: On Habitat Rights for Wild Animals. Environmental Values 26(1), 53–72.
  12. Dan-Cohen, M. (2001). The Value of Ownership. The Journal of Political Philosophy 9(4), 404–434.
  13. Declaration of Rights for Cetaceans: Whales and Dolphins. (2010). Retrieved from <https://www.cetaceanrights.org/>
  14. Donaldson, S. & W. Kymlicka. (2011). Zoopolis: A Political Theory of Animal Rights. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
  15. Donaldson, S. & W. Kymlicka. (2016). Comment: Between Wild and Domesticated: Rethinking Categories and Boundaries in Response to Animal Agency. Animal Ethics in the Age of Humans: Blurring Boundaries in Human-Animal Relationships. B. Bovenkirk and J. Keulartz (eds.). Cham, CH: Springer, 225–242.
  16. Durden, W.N. et al. (2019). Small-Scale Movement Patterns, Activity Budgets, and Association Patterns of Radio-Tagged Indian River Lagoon Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops Truncatus). Aquatic Mammals 45(1), 66–87.
  17. Eskelinen, H.C. et al. (2016). Acoustic behavior associated with cooperative task success in bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus). Animal Cognition 1(19), 789–797.
  18. Faria, C. & Paez. E. (2019). It’s Splitsville. Why Animal Ethics and Environmental Ethics are Incompatible. American Behavioral Scientist 63(8), 1047–1060.
  19. Feinberg, J. (1984). The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law, Vol. 1, Harm to Others. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
  20. Garner, R. (2013). A Theory of Justice for Animals: Animal Rights in a Nonideal World. New York: Oxford University Press.
  21. The Great Ape Project. (2018). Retrieved from <http://www.greatapeproject.uk/>
  22. Hadley, J. (2006). Nonhuman Animal Property: Reconciling Environmentalism and Animal Rights. Journal of Social Philosophy 36(1), 305–315.
  23. Hadley, J. (2015). Animal Property Rights: A Theory of Habitat Rights for Wild Animals. New York, NY: Rowman & Littlefield.
  24. Hadley, J. (2019). Wild Animals as Political Subjects. Routledge Handbook of Animal Ethics. B. Fischer (ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Routledge, 467–476.
  25. Hart, H.L.A. (1955). Are There Any Natural Rights? The Philosophical Review, 64(2), 175–91.
  26. Healey, R., and Pepper, A. (2020). Interspecies Justice: Agency, Self-Determination, and Assent. Philosophical Studies.
  27. Hegel, G.W.F. (1896). Philosophy of Right. London: G. Bell, 51-78.
  28. Honoré, A.M. (1961). “Ownership.” Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence. A.G. Guest (ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  29. Janik, V., & Slater, P. (1998). Context-specific use suggests that bottlenose dolphin signature whistles are cohesion calls. Animal Behavior, 56, 829–38.
  30. Kuczaj II, S.A., and Walker, R.T. (2012). Dolphin Problem Solving. The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Cognition. E.A. Wasserman and T.R. Zentall (eds.), 736–756.
  31. Locke, J. (2005). Two Treatises of Government. New York: Cambridge University Press, 285–302.
  32. Lodi, L., and Tardin, R. (2018). Site fidelity and residency of common bottlenose dolphins (Cetartiodactyla: Delphinidae) in a coastal insular habitat off southeastern Brazil. Pan-American Journal of Aquatic Sciences 13(1), 53–63.
  33. Meager, J.J. et al. (2018). Long-Term Trends in Habitat Use and Site Fidelity by Australian Humpback Dolphins Sousa Sahulensis in a near-Urban Embayment. Marine Ecology Progress Series 603, 227-242.
  34. Milburn, J. (2017). Nonhuman Animals as Property Holders: An Exploration of the Lockean Labour-Mixing Account. Environmental Values 26(1), 629–648.
  35. Milligan, T. (2015). The Political Turn in Animal Rights. Politics and Animals, 6-15.
  36. Nussbaum, M. (2006). Frontiers of Justice: Nationality, Disability, Species Membership. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  37. O’Sullivan, S. (2011). Animals, Equality and Democracy. Basingstroke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
  38. Palmer, C. (2010). Animal Ethics in Context. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
  39. Passadore, C. et al. (2018). High site fidelity and restricted ranging patterns in southern Australian bottlenose dolphins. Ecology and Evolution 8(1), 242–256.
  40. Quick, N., & Janik, V. (2012). Bottlenose dolphins exchange signature whistles when meeting at sea. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 279, 2539–43.
  41. Radin, M.J. (1982). Property and Personhood. Stanford Law Review 34(5), 957–1015.
  42. Ribaric, D. (2018). First Report on Abundance and Distribution of Common Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops Truncatus) in the Natura 2000 Area, Istria, North-Eastern Adriatic Sea. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 98(5), 1039-1053.
  43. Rook, D. (2009). Should great apes have 'human rights'? Web Journal of Current Legal Issues, 2009(1). <http://www.bailii.org/uk/other/journals/WebJCLI/2009/issue1/rook1.html>
  44. Sagoff, M. (1984). Animal Liberation and Environmental Ethics: Bad Marriage, Quick Divorce. Osgood Hall Law Journal 22(2), 297–307.
  45. Stone, A. (2002). Ethical Implications of Hegel’s Philosophy of Nature. British Journal for the History of Philosophy 2(10), 243–260.
  46. Timofeeva, O. (2018). The History of Animals: A Philosophy. New York, NY: Bloomsbury Publishing.
  47. Varner, G. (2008). Can Animal Rights Activists Be Environmentalists? Environmental Ethics. A. Light and H. Rolston III (eds.). Malden: Blackwell Publishing, 95–113.
  48. Vermeulen, E. et al. (2017). Site-Fidelity and Movement Patterns of Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops Truncatus) in Central Argentina: Essential Information for Effective Conservation. Aquatic Conservation-Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 27(1), 282-292.
  49. Waldron, J. (1985). What Is Private Property? Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 5(3), 313–49.
  50. Waldron, J. (1988). The Right to Private Property. New York: Oxford University Press.
  51. Wells, K. (2016). The right to personal property. Politics, Philosophy & Economics, 1–21.
  52. Wells, R.S. et al. (2017). Ranging Patterns of Common Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in Barataria Bay, Louisiana, Following the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill. Endangered Species Research 33, 159-180.
  53. White, T.I. (2007). In Defense of Dolphins: The New Moral Frontier. Malden: Wiley-Blackwell.
  54. Wise, S. (1996). Legal Rights and Nonhuman Animals: The Case for Chimpanzees and Bonobos. Animal Law, 179(2), 179–86.
  55. Wise, S. (2000). Rattling the Cage: Toward Legal Rights for Animals. Boston: Da Capo Press.